Show Notes - Fifth Circuit Short Circuits Qualified Immunity
Watch Episode #54 - “Federal Court Short Circuits Officer's Qualified Immunity Defense”
Description
A big win coming out of the Fifth Circuit Court Of Appeals in the case of Rogers v. Smith. The Court affirmed that a poliee officer who deprived a citizen of their first and fourth amendment rights when they arrested that citizen for criminal libel, despite the police's prior awareness the criminal libel law in question, Louisiana Revised Statutes §14.47 had been ruled unconstitutional by both the Louisiana and United States Supreme Courts.
For these reason the police officers being sued in this case were DENIED qualified immunity and held to have deprived the plaintiff of his civil rights under color of law in accordance with 42 U.S.C. §1983
I also use this case to discuss one of the most common and problematic myths in constitutional law. The writ-of-erasure fallacy. This deals with the crucial distinction between a law that has been ruled unconstitutional by the Courts and the actual repeal of that law by the legislature. The confusion over this legal doctrine frequently has major real world consequences and we discuss what they are.
Links
Rogers v Smith, District Court Eastern District Of Louisiana (2022)
Rogers v. Smith, U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit, Docket
Mitchell, Jonathan F., The Writ-of-Erasure Fallacy (April 6, 2018)
Howard M. Wasserman, A Step Toward a Proper Understanding of Constitutional Litigation (July 12, 2018)
Blackman, Josh, The Irrepressible Myth of Cooper v. Aaron. Georgetown Law Journal, Vol. 107, (2019)
Mass. House OK’s repeal of 19th-century law that criminalized abortion, Boston Globe (June 18, 2018)
Past Episodes
FOLLOW AND SUPPORT
Follow & Support
Pick up a copy of my book - “Constitutional Sleight Of Hand: An explicit history of implied powers” Now Available on Amazon
Legale§e is a podcast that discusses all things constitutional law-- as well as current events in law, politics and culture.
Legale§e is a subscriber-supported project. Please consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.